Trail Tested: Brooks Caldera 3

Heading out the door? Read this article on the new Outside+ app available now on iOS devices for members! Download the app.

Brooks Caldera 3

Weight: 9.7oz (M), 8.0oz (W)
Price: $140
Best features: Snug and comfortable fit, fairly lightweight, versatile and grippy tread.

Room for improvement: Brooks claims the Caldera 3 repels and drains water quickly—in reality, they don’t appear to perform differently from other shoes in this manner. The mesh upper allows water in, and out, but feet remain wet.

I may be dating myself here, but the Brooks Cascadia 7 was the first trail shoe I fell in love with and made trail running the flowing meditation that I enjoy so much today. When I received the Brooks Caldera 3 (women’s version here), I slid them on my foot and a sparkle lit in my eyes.

That day I added the shoe to Strava and nicknamed it, “looks like an Altra, fits like a Nike” because it is more understated than some of Brooks’ other trail shoes and has a similar comfort to the Nike Terra Kiger 3 upon first feel. After running in the Brooks Caldera 3 for a month, I can soundly say I have the same feeling I had upon wearing the Cascadia 7 in 2012—it feels like an extension of my foot.

This shoe follows the general trend we see in trail-running shoes of lighter weight and more cushioning, but has a versatile tread (~3mm lugs) that is great on slickrock, dirt, rocky footing, roads and mud.

The fit of the Caldera 3 is true to size and the lacing allows for premium snugness. The 4mm heel-to-toe drop matched with the natural rocker of the sole makes for a quick and dynamic foot-strike—rare in a shoe with as much cushioning. Brooks added in a gaiter-feature and elastic lace storage that makes the shoe a clear choice for scrambling missions or thru-hikes. The toe-guard is integrated into the upper and is thus not over-developed or prone to coming unglued.

I did run a few days in snowy and muddy conditions and I didn’t find the Caldera 3 to drain any better than other shoes, but they also did not retain water or slosh around.

I can’t emphasize how nice this shoe feels. I consider the Caldera 3 as a go-to daily-driver for mixed road/trail runs as well as a fantastic option for mountain adventures and trail races. In comparison to the previous Caldera 2, the Caldera 3 is slightly lighter, has slightly less drop, fits more comfortably, and isn’t quite as stiff. This is the trail shoe I want to wear while at work, during my midday run and racing on the weekend.

—Jeff Colt is a professional trail runner based out of Redstone, Co. When he is not running on trails, he can be found tending bar or working as a PR-professional for Backbone Media. Jeff most recently placed third at the Bandera 100K.

Trending on Trail Runner Magazine

Want to Know What It Takes to Finish at Western States? Just Ask Hellah Sidibe.

Find out what happened when this six-year run streaker and HOKA Global Athlete Ambassador took on an iconic ultramarathon in California's Sierra Nevada